English prof ejected from NYC Starbucks due to apparent linguistic differences

August 19, 2010

OK, coffee usually doesn't have a tax connection unless you're working on your return late on April 15.

But this story is just too funny or sad, depending on whether you're a fan of the Seattle-based coffee shop giant and/or just how strict a grammarian you are, not to share.

Lynne Rosenthal, a college English professor from Manhattan, told the New York Post that three cops
forcibly ejected her from an Upper West Side Starbucks earlier this week "after
she got into a dispute with a counterperson — make that barista — for refusing
to place her order by the coffee chain's rules
."

NEW YORK - AUGUST 5: Beverage cups featuring the logo of Starbucks Coffee are seen in the new flagship store on 42nd Street August 5, 2003 in New York City. The Seattle-based coffee company has emerged as the largest food chain in the Manhattan borough of New York with 150 outlets. (Photo by Stephen Chernin/Getty Images)

Rosenthal said she simply wanted a multigrain bagel. The Starbucks staffer asked her if she wanted butter or cheese with it.

And that's when the trouble began.

"I refused to say 'without butter or cheese.' When you go to Burger King, you don't have to list the six things you don't want," Rosenthal told the newspaper. "Linguistically, it's stupid, and I'm a stickler for correct English."

Rosenthal admitted to yelling "I want my multigrain bagel!", to which the Starbucks employee replied, "You're not going to get anything unless you say butter or cheese!"

It sounds like both Rosenthal and the barista need to switch to decaf!

Hat tip: TaxProf Blog

Related posts:

Want to tell your friends about this
blog post? Click the Tweet
This
or Digg This buttons below or use the
Share
This
icon to spread the word via e-mail,
Facebook and other popular applications. Thanks!

Share:

The More Tax Posts tab at the top of this page will take you to, well, more tax posts. You also can search below for a tax topic. 

Latest Posts
The latest Dirty Dozen tax scam list is familiar because too many are still falling for the schemes

March 5, 2026

Tax filing season is also peak time for tax scams. Be on the lookout for…

Read More
Hello Tax Season 2026

Happy New Tax Year! Are you ready to file your 2025 tax return? I know, too early to ask. But Tax Day 2026 will be here before we realize it. The Internal Revenue Service deadline to file and pay any tax we owe is the regular April 15 date this year. It’s also Tax Day for most of the states that collect income taxes from their residents, which is most of the states! If that seems too far away right now, don’t worry. As is the case every tax season, the ol’ blog’s tips and other tax reminders should help all of us meet our state and federal responsibilities. Procrastinators also will want to keep an eye on the countdown clock just below. It tracks how much time we have until April’s Tax Day, just in case we put off our annual tax task until the absolutely final hours and decide we need to instead get an extension request into the IRS by that date. (Note: I’m in the Central Time Zone, so adjust accordingly for where you live.)

Comments
  • “Stickler for correct English” to the point where the police are called? Yep, decaf (and maybe valium?) for both.

  • I can’t believe this professor couldn’t say, “No, thank you.” That would have answered the question. Is that so objectionable? She didn’t have had to say, “I would like neither cheese nor butter.”
    Anyone with issues as irrational as that should consider buying bagels at the grocery store and toasting them at home. Or maybe some therapy…

  • Sorry — this isn’t news until the barista pulls a Steven Slater on the customer.

Leave your comment