Supreme Court reverses Sotomayor case

June 29, 2009

The Supreme Court has ruled that white firefighters in New Haven, Conn., were unfairly denied promotions because of their race.

The case has received special attention because Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor was part of an appellate panel that issued the ruling that was today overturned.

Legal experts say the 5-to-4 High Court ruling could alter employment practices across the country and make it harder to prove discrimination.

Sotomayor on taxes: Capitol Hill is obviously paying close attention to all of Sotomayor's prior rulings, not just the high-profile ones.

Those in the tax world, however, don't have a lot to examine.

"Sotomayor has not written extensively in the area of taxation," notes the Congressional Research Service (CRS), "and it is not possible to draw conclusions about her judicial philosophy from the tax cases in which she has been involved."

That difficulty notwithstanding, CRS has released Judge Sonia Sotomayor: Analysis of Selected Opinions, which includes a section on her tax-relevant rulings.

I know all you fellow tax geeks will want to examine the CRS analysis carefully at your own pace, so I won't spoil that thrill by repeating its contents here. Enjoy!

And we'll have to wait and see if any tax-related questions come up during Sotomayor's confirmation hearings later this summer.

Share:

The More Tax Posts tab at the top of this page will take you to, well, more tax posts. You also can search below for a tax topic. 

Latest Posts
The latest Dirty Dozen tax scam list is familiar because too many are still falling for the schemes

March 5, 2026

Tax filing season is also peak time for tax scams. Be on the lookout for…

Read More
Hello Tax Season 2026

Happy New Tax Year! Are you ready to file your 2025 tax return? I know, too early to ask. But Tax Day 2026 will be here before we realize it. The Internal Revenue Service deadline to file and pay any tax we owe is the regular April 15 date this year. It’s also Tax Day for most of the states that collect income taxes from their residents, which is most of the states! If that seems too far away right now, don’t worry. As is the case every tax season, the ol’ blog’s tips and other tax reminders should help all of us meet our state and federal responsibilities. Procrastinators also will want to keep an eye on the countdown clock just below. It tracks how much time we have until April’s Tax Day, just in case we put off our annual tax task until the absolutely final hours and decide we need to instead get an extension request into the IRS by that date. (Note: I’m in the Central Time Zone, so adjust accordingly for where you live.)

Comments
  • I really appreciate you taking the time to look at the issue. Thanks for the detail I really appreciate your work.
    LLCB

  • I have to say, I’m glad this was reversed. I feel if you are going to give a test, then you go with the top scorers. If they are all white oh well. If they are all minorities, then all minorities get the spots. It seems to be blatent reverse discrimination that has been allowed to go on for years. It needs to be a level playing field, not tilted in one way or the other. None of this 25% of promotions have to be minoroty (even if they didn’t do well on the test). Why give them the spots for free. They need to earn it like anyone else would have to. They can get study guides and put in time like any other person who is trying to improve themselves. Nobody should get a job based on race. It needs to be the most qualifed candidate regardless of race, sex or any other factor. If you hire or promote by a test, then the top scorers get the positions right down from the top.

  • For american people this is great judgement.

Leave your comment