Lessons learned from being tax Peeping Toms

June 14, 2015

The hubby says my dream of a rural retreat, miles and miles and miles from other people is BS. I wouldn't be able to survive, he contends, without neighbors to spy on.

OK, maybe he has a point. I do sometimes seem like Gladys Kravitz's much younger sister. But, honestly, you wouldn't believe some of the things that the people on my block do! They are demanding to be watched!

I know I am not alone. Let's all be honest here. Humans are nosy.

That's why reality television rules the airwaves. Magazines full of quasi-celebrities fill store racks. Heck, our curiosity about others keeps the Internet in business.

In fact, we've recently had two examples of our nosiness when it comes to taxes, one unintentional and the other revealed willingly by the taxpayer. 

Jock taxes and retirement savings: Let's start with the tax data that was revealed inadvertently to tax Peeping Toms.

Andrew McCutchen, the all-star-center fielder for the Pittsburgh Pirates, left a pay stub in Wrigley Field's visiting teams' locker room. It was picked up later by a Major League Baseball fan touring the Cubs' home and subsequently posted online.

McCutchen wasn't too upset about his pay info getting out. As he noted, the amount isn't a big secret and no personal data that could lead to identity theft was disseminated.

Thanks, Cutch, for being so understanding, since the details about that May paycheck, as you even pointed out, offer us a look at your myriad taxes. From there, we get several tax and financial lessons.

First, #22 also is an all-star when it comes to his pay. In addition to making sure he remits all the jock taxes due on his earnings in various MLB states and cities, McCutchen has his bi-weekly income directly deposited so he doesn't have to worry about it.

Maxing out post-work money: Plus, he maxes out his 401(k) contribution.

Some online examiners of McCutchen's pay stub slammed the multimillionaire for putting only $1,500 away in his workplace retirement account.

But paycheck size doesn't matter here. McCutchen is bound by the same tax law limits all of us are, which is a maximum of $18,000 in 2015 that can be contributed tax-free to a 401(k). Money put into a workplace retirement account beyond that limit would be taxed before going it's taken from his pay. Presumably, McCutchen can find other, better vehicles into which to put that extra cash.

As for his 401(k), however, he is putting in all the tax-deferred money that the tax code allows. Contributing $1,500 twice a month comes to $3,000. Multiply that by MLB's six months of regular season pay and you get $18,000.

Good job, Cutch. Now just be sure to stick your future pay stubs more firmly in your travel bag.

Investments, tax rates and refunds: The only people who give rich athletes a run for their money are politicians. Many of them are hoping to be elected president in 2016, including Carly Fiorina.

Fiorina is one of ever-growing field of Republican presidential nominee hopefuls. She and her husband Frank also are very rich, worth around $59 million according to the financial disclosure statement (one's eventually required from all candidates) she filed.

But Fiorina took a further financial step, giving political Peeping Toms a closer look at her personal finances. She also released her 2012 and 2013 tax returns; no peek yet at her 2014 forms as she got an extension to file that 1040. 

Such tax filing revelations are common, but usually not until a candidate is his or her party's official nominee.

We can speculate on the political reasons for the early tax data. But I'd rather look at what we can learn from Fiorina's 2012 and 2013 taxes.

First, like most wealthy folks, the bulk of Fiorina's earnings are from investments, not wages. Investment earnings generally are taxed at a lower rate.

That's why, despite reporting income of more than a million both tax years, which would put her in the top 39.6 percent tax bracket if the money was ordinary, that is, wage, income, Fiorina has an effective federal tax rate of just 20 percent.

States' tax tolls: Her tax rate goes up about 10 more percentage points when you add in state and local taxes. And Fiorina and her husband faced a lot of state taxes. The couple had to file returns in no fewer than 17 states in 2013.

While that's a lot of filing, it's a situation more of us less wealthy filers also are finding ourselves facing, to a degree.

States and cities are grasping at every cent they can, meaning that if you worked in a state for a time, you owed its treasury taxes. Even if you didn't work there, but got money, say as telecommuting income or from rental property in the state, you still owe that state taxes.

The Fiorinas obviously can afford to hire a phalanx of accountants and tax advisers to ensure they don't get tripped up by multi-state taxes. For the rest of us, it requires paying attention and hiring tax help we can afford or hoping our tax software can help us sort through the requirements.

Then there's the matter of refunds. Fiorina overpaid Uncle Sam $159,122 in 2012; her 2013 refund was $128,978.

Yes, she and her husband had those refund amounts credited toward the coming tax year's estimated tax payment. But still, no one regardless of earnings should be giving the federal government an interest-free loan.

You also might find these items of interest:

Share:

The More Tax Posts tab at the top of this page will take you to, well, more tax posts. You also can search below for a tax topic. 

Latest Posts
The latest Dirty Dozen tax scam list is familiar because too many are still falling for the schemes

March 5, 2026

Tax filing season is also peak time for tax scams. Be on the lookout for…

Read More
Hello Tax Season 2026

Happy New Tax Year! Are you ready to file your 2025 tax return? I know, too early to ask. But Tax Day 2026 will be here before we realize it. The Internal Revenue Service deadline to file and pay any tax we owe is the regular April 15 date this year. It’s also Tax Day for most of the states that collect income taxes from their residents, which is most of the states! If that seems too far away right now, don’t worry. As is the case every tax season, the ol’ blog’s tips and other tax reminders should help all of us meet our state and federal responsibilities. Procrastinators also will want to keep an eye on the countdown clock just below. It tracks how much time we have until April’s Tax Day, just in case we put off our annual tax task until the absolutely final hours and decide we need to instead get an extension request into the IRS by that date. (Note: I’m in the Central Time Zone, so adjust accordingly for where you live.)

Comments
Leave the first comment