Cleveland’s jock tax method ruled illegal
Ohio Supreme Court sides with former NFL players

April 30, 2015

Tonight belongs to future National Football League stars. The young men who will be selected during the NFL's annual players' draft in Chicago the evening of April 30 are looking forward to lucrative careers in America's most popular sports league.

Earlier today, however, the spotlight was on some former NFL players who were victorious in their tax fight against the home of the Cleveland Browns.

NFL's Cowboys vs Lion photo by SKBWho will my Dallas Cowboys pick in this year's NFL draft? With Jerry Jones in charge, it's always exciting!

Cleveland's bad jock tax: Former Chicago Bears linebacker Hunter Hillenmeyer and former Indianapolis Colts center Jeff Saturday sued Cleveland for what they said were illegally collected jock taxes.

The city, according to the men's separate lawsuits, illegally taxes all athletes on a visiting team for every game, even players who are hurt or don't attend the game.

Hillenmeyer paid $5,062 to Cleveland; Saturday's tax bill was $3,294. The former players were taxed on games at which they were not present.

The pair said their legal actions were not about the money, but the principle. No person in any line of work should have to pay tax when they haven't provided any taxable services within a tax jurisdiction.

Court validation: The former NFLers got what they wanted when the Ohio Supreme Court today (April 30) agreed with them.

"Cleveland's power to tax reaches only that portion of a nonresident's compensation that was earned by work performed in Cleveland," the justices ruled.

The Buckeye State's high court also found that the games-played method used by the city to determine its portion of taxable income from visiting athletes violated due process.

The court ordered Cleveland to refund the jock taxes it illegally collected from Saturday and Hillenmeyer.

The decision not only means that Cleveland will collect less in taxes from professional athletes playing there in future games, but that it might be looking at doling out refunds to others who were improperly taxed.

You also might find these items of interest:

Share:

The More Tax Posts tab at the top of this page will take you to, well, more tax posts. You also can search below for a tax topic. 

Latest Posts
Failing to create a tax deduction bunching strategy is Thanksgiving season’s first Tax Turkey to Avoid

November 21, 2026

This strutting turkey has no regrets, but too many taxpayers do. That’s because they don’t…

Read More
TAX-SAVVY WAYS 
TO WRAP UP 2026

It’s over! With October’s extended filing deadline behind us, it is now time to focus on year-end moves to reduce your 2026 tax bill. 

You’ll find ways to do just that on the Tax Tips page (see the More Tax Posts drop-down menu at the top of the blog), as well as the separate tax tip pages for each month, notably October through December. If you’re on the Tax Tips page, you’ll find a monthly list at the end of this column. If you’re on another blog page, you can head straight to the October tips; at the bottom of that tips page you’ll find links to all the other 11 months’ collections of tax advice.

Not to spoil what you’ll find in that tax advice, but it does cover such things as tax deductions for charitable donations, investment moves that could reduce tax due, and ways to max out your tax-favored retirement savings. 

Finally, as the year winds down, things get hectic. There are lots of other things to occupy our time, like the much more fun upcoming holidays. But don’t lose sight of taxes, since timing is key. To be of use, most tax moves must be made by the end of the tax year. That’s Thursday, Dec. 31, which also is the last business day of the year. 

So that you don’t miss that final tax year deadline, also keep an eye on the countdown clock below. It will keep you on top of just how much time is left to make important, tax-saving moves. (Note: I’m in the Central Time Zone, so adjust accordingly for where you live.)

Comments
Leave your comment